navigation logo
Skip to Main Content
  • About Us
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Catering Menu
  • Facebook pageInstagram page
  • Catering
  • Events
  • Order
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
Elsie's Plate & Pie logo
  • Facebook pageInstagram page
  • About Us
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Catering Menu
  • Catering
  • Events
  • Order
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards

Catering Menu

Appetizers

Smokey 3 Cheese Pimento Platter

$60.00/Party Tray
Smoked gouda, cheddar, and pepper jack on crostini with our Arlington House Pineapple pepper jelly (feeds 15-20)

Cajun Crawfish Queso

$75.00/Half Pan
Louisiana crawfish in a cheese and red peppers queso, served with pork skins (feeds 12-14)

Seafood Lafourche Bisque

$60.00/Half Pan
Louisiana shrimp and crawfish, roasted red pepper and smoked gouda (feeds 8-10)

Boudin & Pepper Jack Balls

$60.00/Tray of 50
Homemade boudin, mixed with pepper jack cheese and fried. Served with remoulade

Boudin Slider Platter

$75.00/Tray of 25 Sliders
Boudin patty deep fried served with pepper jack cheese and topped with Arlington House peach pepper jelly

Salads

Arlington House Salad

$50.00/Half Pan
$85.00/Full Pan
A bed of fresh spinach with tomato, red onion, toasted pecans, bleu cheese crumbles, croutons and strawberry pepper jelly vinaigrette (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Big Better Blue Salad

$50.00/Half Pan
$85.00/Full Pan
Crispy romaine lettuce topped with tomato and cucumber, served with a side of avocado, boiled eggs, croutons, balsamic vinaigrette and our bleu cheese dressing (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Ruby Greens Salad

$50.00/Half Pan
$85.00/Full Pan
Baby greens topped with smoked gouda, tomato, bacon, and fried onions. Served with a side of avocado, croutons and roasted garlic vinaigrette (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Pimento Salad

$60.00/Half Pan
$100.00/Full Pan
Baby greens with a hearty serving of our 3 cheese pimento, toasted pecans, green onions, and our strawberry pepper jelly vinaigrette (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Savory Pies

Seafood Pot Pie

$100.00/Half Pan
$180.00/Full Pan
Crawfish, Shrimp & Crab in a roasted red pepper cream, baked with a flaky crust (half pan feeds 8-10) (full pan feeds 16-20)

LA Poulet Pot Pie

$60.00/Half Pan
$110.00/Full Pan
Smoked Chicken and roasted peppers in a tasso cream sauce, baked in our flaky crust (half pan feeds 8-10) (full pan feeds 16-20)

Natchitoches Meat Pies

$50.00/Tray of 10
$90.00/Tray of 20
Beef and pork, Louisiana spices, fried in a handmade crust, served with Bedford sauce.

Crawfish Hand Pies

$70.00/Tray of 10
$130.00/Tray of 20
Louisiana crawfish, corn and sausage from the boil, fried in a handmade crust, served with Cajun Cream.

Carl’s Tomato Pie

$40.00/9" Pie
Roasted tomatoes and creamy mozzarella baked in flaky crust, finished with fresh tomato and pesto (9” pie / Feeds 4-6)

Crustless Crab Pie

$100.00/Half Pan
Louisiana Blue Crab, a cheese blend, finished with fresh diced tomatoes in a garlic vinaigrette (feeds 8-10)

Entrees

Crawfish Queso Mac n Cheese

$65.00/Half Pan
$120.00/Full Pan
Pasta tossed with our crawfish queso and baked with pepper jack

Crawfish Bisque

$90.00/Half Pan
Louisiana crawfish stewed in a dark roux gravy, served with rice and fried crawfish fritters (feeds 8-12)

Shrimp Platter

$75.00/Tray of 50
$140.00/Tray of 100
Jumbo shrimp either buttermilk battered and fried, or grilled. Served with remoulade sauce.

Fried Catfish Platter

$60.00/25 Strips
$110.00/50 Strips
Catfish fillets buttermilk battered and fried, served with remoulade.

Fried Chicken Fingers

$45.00/25 Chicken Fingers
$85.00/50 Chicken Fingers
Crunchy and juicy chickens fingers, fried golden brown.

Red Beans & Rice

$50.00/Half Pan
$90.00/Full Pan
Our Louisiana style red beans and sausage served with rice (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 16-20)

Sweet Pies

Please allow 2-3 days notice for specialty pie orders

Eye of the Tiger Pie

$27.00/9" Pie
An Elsie's classic, lemon ice box pie, topped with blueberry whipped cream.

Rocky Road Pie

$27.00/9" Pie
Graham Cracker Crust, light and fluffy chocolate filling loaded with marshmallows and almonds.

Key Lime Pie

$25.00/9" Pie
Classic Key Lime Pie with our graham cracker crust and a meringue

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

$28.00/9" Pie
Chocolate crust, whipped peanut butter filling, topped with a chocolate ganache

Berry Streusel

$28.00/9" Pie
Seasonal berries in traditional pastry crust, topped with streusel made with oats and pecans

Mid-City Mud

$26.00/9" Pie
Chocolate filling over a layer of cream cheese in a graham cracker crust, topped with whipped cream, pecans, and chocolate sauce.

Strawberry Chess

$27.00/9" Pie
Classic chess pie with fresh strawberries added in.

Mini-Mini Pie Tray

$50.00/30
A tray of our pies, only bite sized!

Dessert Pie

Feel free to request any of our specialty or regular menu pies!
  • Order
  • Catering
  • Jobs