Skip to main content
  • Elsie's Plate & Pie logo top - Homepage
    Elsie's Plate & Pie logo scroll - Homepage
  • Go to top
  • About Us
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Catering Menu
  • Catering
  • Events
  • Order
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Merch
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Yelp page
Elsie's Plate & Pie logo top - HomepageElsie's Plate & Pie logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Yelp page
  • About Us
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Catering Menu
  • Catering
  • Events
  • Order
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Merch

Catering Menu

Small Bites

Smokey 3 Cheese Pimento Platter
$60.00/Tray

Smoked gouda, cheddar, and pepper jack on crostini with our Arlington House Pineapple pepper jelly (feeds 15-20)

Cajun Crawfish Queso
$60.00/Full pan: 1/3 queso, 2/3 pork skins

Louisiana crawfish in a cheese and red peppers queso, served with pork skins (feeds 12-14)

Boudin & Pepper Jack Balls
$50.00/Half pan (35)

House-made boudin, mixed with pepper jack cheese and fried. Served with remoulade

Boudin & Pepper Jack Egg Rolls
$60.00/25 count

House-made boudin mixed with pepper jack cheese and fried in a crispy egg roll. Served with homemade thai chili sauce.

Fried Okra
$40.00/Half pan

Hand-battered and fried, served with remoulade

Smoked Wings
$45.00/24 count

Slow-smoked, baked, then flash fried. Tossed in our signature dry rub and served with blueberry pepper jelly BBQ sauce and blacked ranch

Fruit Platter
$60.00/Tray

An assortment of pineapple, strawberries, grapes and blueberries.

Veggie Platter
$50.00/Tray

An assortment of brocolli, cauliflower, carrots, zucchini, and cherry tomatoes. Served with blackened ranch.

Mini Crab Cakes
$60.00/Half pan (24)
$120.00/Full pan (60)

Southern classic with lump crab meat, fried and served with remoulade

Salads

Arlington House Salad
$50.00/Half pan
$85.00/Full pan

A bed of fresh spinach with tomato, red onion, toasted pecans, bleu cheese crumbles, croutons and strawberry pepper jelly vinaigrette (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Big Better Blue Salad
$50.00/Half pan
$85.00/Full pan

Crispy romaine lettuce topped with tomato and cucumber, served with a side of avocado, boiled eggs, croutons, balsamic reduction, and our bleu cheese dressing (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Ruby Greens Salad
$50.00/Half pan
$85.00/Full pan

Baby greens topped with smoked gouda, tomato, bacon, and fried onions. Served with a side of avocado, croutons and roasted garlic vinaigrette (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Pimento Salad
$50.00/Half pan
$85.00/Full pan

Baby greens with a hearty serving of our 3 cheese pimento, toasted pecans, green onions, and our strawberry pepper jelly vinaigrette (half pan feeds 8-12) (full pan feeds 18-22)

Berry Feta Kick Salad
$50.00/Half pan
$85.00/Full pan

Spring mix with pepper jelly vinaigrette, topped with fresh strawberries, feta, pecans, balsamic reduction and fried jalapenos

Stuff on Bread

Fried Chicken Sliders
$75.00/Tray (24)

Crispy fried chicken on slider buns topped with pepper jack cheese and strawberry pepper jelly.

Mini Shrimp Poboys
$50.00/Full pan (15)

Fried shrimp on poboy bread. Served with Arlington sauce, mayo, lettuce, tomato, and pickles on the side

Elsie's Club Sandwich Tray
$65.00/Tray (20)

The Elsie's Club Sandwich - only smaller! Compart Ham, smoked turkey, bacon, havarti and avocado. Dressed with remoulade, lettuce and tomato.

Pimento BLT Tray
$65.00/Tray (20)

Crispy bacon and our house-made 3-cheese smokey pimento on sourdough with lettuce and tomato.

Boudin Slider Platter
$75.00/Tray (24)

Boudin patty deep fried, dressed with pepper jack cheese and Arlington House peach pepper jelly on a slider bun.

Savory Pies

Louisiana Poulet Pot Pie
$50.00/9" pie

Smoked chicken and roasted peppers in a tasso cream sauce baked in a flaky crust.

Seafood Pot Pie
$90.00/9" pie

Crawfish, shrimp & crab in a roasted red pepper cream baked in a flaky crust

Carl’s Tomato Pie
$40.00/9" pie

Roasted tomatoes and creamy mozzarella baked in flaky crust, finished with fresh tomato and pesto (9” pie / Feeds 4-6)

Natchitoches Meat Pies
$50.00/10 count
$90.00/20 count

Beef and pork, Louisiana spices, fried in a handmade crust, served with Bedford sauce.

Crawfish Hand Pies
$70.00/10 count
$130.00/20 count

Louisiana crawfish, corn and sausage from the boil, fried in a handmade crust, served with Cajun Cream.

Crustless Crab Pie
$100.00/Half pan

Louisiana Blue Crab, a cheese blend, finished with fresh diced tomatoes in a garlic vinaigrette (feeds 8-10)

Entrees

Louisiana Poulet Pot Pie Mac
$50.00/Half pan
$90.00/Full pan

Smoked chicken and roasted peppers in a tasso cream sauce with gemelli pasta (half pan feeds 8-10) (full pan feeds 16-20)

Seafood Pot Pie Mac
$75.00/Half pan
$140.00/Full pan

Crawfish, shrimp & crab in a roasted red pepper cream with gemelli pasta (half pan feeds 8-10) (full pan feeds 16-20)

Crawfish Queso Mac & Cheese
$65.00/Half pan
$120.00/Full pan

Gemelli pasta tossed with our crawfish queso and baked with pepper jack

Shrimp Platter
$75.00/50 count
$140.00/100 count

Jumbo shrimp either buttermilk battered and fried, or grilled. Served with remoulade sauce.

Fried Chicken Fingers
$45.00/25 count
$85.00/50 count

Buttermilk fried chicken fingers, fried golden brown. Served with your choice of house-made honey mustard, blackened ranch, or blueberry BBQ sauce.

Red Beans & Rice with Fried Chicken
$80.00/Half pan

Our Louisiana style red beans and sausage served with rice and fried chicken bites

Crawfish Étouffée
$75.00/Half pan

A Louisiana staple - crawfish in a rich, buttery gravy with Cajun spices, served with rice

Soups

Seafood Lafourche Bisque
$30.00/Quart

Louisiana shrimp and crawfish, roasted red pepper, tomato and smoked gouda

Roasted Tomato Soup
$20.00/Quart

Classic creamy tomato basil soup made with house-roasted tomatoes

Crawfish Bisque with Fried Crawfish Fritters
$80.00/Half pan

Louisiana crawfish stewed in a dark roux gravy, served with rice and 25 fried crawfish fritters (feeds 8-12)

Sides

Grant's Grits
$35.00/Half pan
Bedford Coleslaw
$35.00/Half pan
Parmesan Whipped Potatoes
$45.00/Half pan
Mac & Cheese
$45.00/Half pan
Pimento Cheese Mac
$50.00/Half pan

Our signature smokey three cheese pimento with gemelli pasta.

Brussels Sprouts
$45.00/Half pan
Sauteed Green Beans
$35.00/Half pan
Red Beans & Rice
$50.00/Half pan
$90.00/Full pan

Our Louisiana style red beans and sausage served with rice

Roasted Asparagus
$50.00/Half pan

With feta, balsamic, and sliced almonds.

Elsie's Blackened Potato Chips
$20.00/Full pan

Fried and sprinkled with house-made blackened seasoning

Sweet Pies

Single Serving Mini Pies
$60.00/10 count

We offer a smaller four inch version of our pies for more variety - or if you don't like to share! Options include Chocolate Cream, S’Mores, Coconut Cream, Apple, Peanut Butter Cup, Lemon Ice Box, Eye of the Tiger, Key Lime, Red Velvet, Cosmic Brownie, pecan, and many more. Minimum 10 per flavor.

Apple Hand Pies
$50.00/10 count

Our apple pie filling in a hand pie form and deep fried. Served with spice glaze.

Cherry Hand Pies
$50.00/10 count

Our cherry pie filling in a hand pie form and deep fried. Served with cherry glaze.

Classic Pies

The staples! ** Please allow 2-3 days notice for specialty pie orders **

Chocolate Cream
$28.00/9" pie

Graham cracker crust with chocolate filling and topped with whipped cream.

Turtle Pie
$28.00/9" pie

Graham cracker crust with chocolate filling and topped with roasted pecans, caramel, and whipped cream

Coconut Cream
$28.00/9" pie

Rich and creamy coconut custard in a pastry crust topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut shavings

Lemon Ice Box
$28.00/9" pie

Sweet lemon custard baked in a vanilla wafer crust and topped with whipped cream

Key Lime
$30.00/9" Pie

Classic Key Lime Pie with our graham cracker crust and a meringue

Pecan Pie
$30.00/9" pie

A southern staple. We also offer variations of Chocolate Pecan and Bourbon Pecan

Apple Pie
$28.00/9" pie

Apple slices and spices baked in a flaky pastry crust

Cherry Pie
$30.00/9" pie

Cherries baked in a flaky pastry crust

Signature Pies

A few options from our vast pie portfolio. If you don't see something you like - call and ask! We are happy to accommodate special requests. ** Please allow 2-3 days notice for specialty pie orders **

Eye of the Tiger
$28.00/9" pie

An Elsie's classic, lemon ice box pie, topped with blueberry whipped cream.

Chocolate, Chocolate, Chocolate
$30.00/9" pie

Chocolate crust, chocolate filling, chocolate whip cream

Tarte à la Bouille
$30.00/9" pie

A traditional Cajun custard pie - like a sugar cookie crust filled with rich vanilla pudding.

S'mores
$28.00/9" pie

Graham cracker crust, chocolate filling, toasted marshmallow fluff.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
$30.00/9" pie

Chocolate crust, whipped peanut butter filling, topped with a chocolate ganache

Blackberry Margarita
$30.00/9" pie

Key lime pie with a blackberry-infused whipped cream.

Cookies & Cream
$30.00/9" pie

Chocolate crust, cookies and cream custard filling, topped with Oreo-infused whipped cream and crumbled Oreo cookies.

King Cake Pie
$30.00/9" pie

Cinnamon toast crunch & marshmallow crust, sweet cream cheese filling, cinnamon sugar glaze, Mardi Gras sprinkles. ** King Cake Season ONLY! **

The Mini-Mini Pie Tray

A tray of 2" bite-size pies. Available in a variety of flavors.

The Mini-Mini Pie Tray
$50.00/30 pies

A tray of our pies, only bite sized! Available flavors: Chocolate Cream, Turtle, S'mores, Coconut Cream, Almond Joy, Peanut Butter Cup, Eye of the Tiger, Key Lime, Triple Chocolate. One flavor per tray

  • Order
  • Catering
  • Jobs